In Division 2, Team 3 of Craig Linton, Kristian Skotzen and Bob Porteous travelled to Bathgate to take on high flying West Lothian 3 in one of those fixtures which was potentially a “must not lose” game. A win would see Team 3 end the first half of the season in third place in the Division and only a point behind their opponents. A draw would keep them in touch. A loss and not only would they fall off the pace and make it very difficult for the second half of the season, but they would harm Team 2’s season as West Lothian would leapfrog them on game difference to lead the Division. So not much on the line! Keith MacKay v Bob was first up and in a topsy turvy contest Bob came out on top 11-8 in the fifth. Andrew Morrison is WL’s number 1 and he proved why with a 3-1 win v Kristian in Game 2. Craig then took on Noel Sison in a cracking match that went the distance. A 12-10 defeat for Craig was a hard one to take. Match 4 also went the distance, this time Bob not able to get over the line as he fell to Andrew in five ends. 3-1 to the hosts and the Midlothian side were in trouble. Craig got the visitors within 1 again with a straightforward win v Keith but an equally straightforward win for Noel v Kristian restored the two game advantage. The doubles saw Craig and Kristian storm through the first set 11-2 – but then the wheels came off as the next 3 were lost – 5-2 down and on the brink of defeat. Andrew v Craig and Noel v Bob were next up, and both went to five ends – but the Penicuik players lost both of them and the win was secured for the hosts. Kristian won the final match of the night but a 7-3 defeat for Team 3 damages their promotion aspirations. It could have been so different – FIVE 5 enders and only one of them went the way of the visitors. Two of the four losses were deuce in the fifth – oh if only….
With only one match this week, there was an argument that we shouldn’t bother with a Player of the Week Award. That argument was strengthened by the fact that all three players only won 1. Decision made! Instead, we are giving a special “Player of the 1st Half of The Season Award” – that’s a really snazzy title, not!
Now this is a tough one. If we are basing it on averages in the League, then Krzysztof is top dog – 93% in Division 2. He's so committed that he's back in Poland for Xmas and despite the weather still practicing on an outside table (as pictured). But he’s only played 15 out of a possible 27 games and according to his teammates, the 4 matches he’s missed have all been against really good opposition!! If we are basing it on improvement then a big shout out to Roscoe who has stepped up a Division and has still improved his average. If we are basing it on commitment to the Club, then James has to be in with a shout – not only captaining Team 3, available to play up for Team 1, organising all our TT purchases, getting our kit organised but also available to step into the breach when the McDonell coaches “have better things to do” first thing on a Saturday morning. But none of those are winning the award this time.
The award goes to a Club member (we still claim him as one of us) who hasn’t actually played this season for us. For anyone who has not read his story, head over to the Scottish Vets Website where you can read a cracking article written by the man himself, Steve Collins. A horrendous diagnosis in May 2024 put him out of action – for many of us it would have been difficult to pick ourselves up and battle on. Our Club President still remembers with horror and shock the phone call he received telling him of the news. But he also remembers the courage, strength of character and sheer determination which was clear from Steve to battle against the odds. We could all take a leaf out of Steve’s book – his positivity was astounding. Immunotherapy courses have followed and throughout it all Steve has kept up his positive outlook and a great desire to get back to playing TT. Fast forward to September and the nutter entered the Veterans Banded Event – a gruelling day’s table tennis for anyone! He survived it and has continued to turn out – most recently seen by us at the Scottish National League! Not quite ready to come back into Edinburgh League action but we’ll keep on at him! As the end of 2024 approaches, all of us at the Club send Steve our very best wishes as he continues his battle. Your award awaits you when you get over to Penicuik Steve!
As for controversies, we don’t normally do any in the week before Christmas but this season we have a special request to look back a few weeks. The player himself asked us to get his name into lights. So, we turn the clock back to the Scottish National League in November. In Penicuik’s match against the Joe Wilson Club, that old topic of “over exuberance” comes under the microscope. In a fairly important match, the Joe Wilson entourage, led by one of our favourite players, Noah Fletcher (who wasn’t even in the team) seemed to applaud and cheer on every good point won by their player, as well as cheering on any average shots where he won a point or even any mistakes from his opponent. Oh, how we hate that type of behaviour! It’s just not good sportsmanship. There were two or three occasions when the applause came after a net/edge from the Joe Wilson player. Not one to shy away from such conduct, our Penicuik player indicated that it was outrageous to be clapping in such a situation. The response from Noah was that he / the entourage “never saw the lucky element of the shot”. Hmmm – maybe. Or maybe they were just doing it to get under the player’s skin. In the end, the match went to five terrific ends and the “over the score” support didn’t impact the result. But that’s not the point. As we’ve said on numerous occasions, we have no problems with vociferous support and encouragement, or player led cheers / screams of joy – but surely only when a good shot has resulted in the point being won. Cheering on an opponent’s unforced errors is poor and should be removed from the game. Ah well, that should please Noah who was disappointed that he hadn’t made it into our Report earlier in the season – Merry Xmas Noah.
No more controversial issues to address – it’s the season of goodwill after all! With the festive season upon us we wish all our Members and TT friends (particularly those pantomime villains from West Lothian) a Merry Xmas and best wishes for 2025.